Errata
Quiet in San Fran11 May 2008
—• CONTENTS •—
— Errata Movie Podcast —
April 2003
2003, U.S.
director: Christopher Guest

A Mighty Wind is often called a mockumentary and has been compared to serious documentaries such as The Weavers: Wasn't That A Time (which I have not seen). But director Christopher Guest hasn't tried very hard to make something that looks like a documentary. The movie drifts uneasily between documentary and dramatic modes without establishing a clear stylistic difference between the two. This may be one of the reasons that it reminds me of Robert Altman's Nashville more than it does a music documentary. Although Nashville has ostensibly more serious aspirations, much of the fun of watching it comes from its caricatures of musicians who take themselves more seriously than we do, and the same is true of A Mighty Wind. Nashville tries to catch the musicians on the rise or at their peaks, whereas A Mighty Wind picks them up well after their primes. Both movies juggle large casts of actors who write and perform original songs that mimic the genre, with varying degrees of accuracy, and both movies build to concerts with dramatic conclusions.

Guest arguably shows more compassion for his central characters than does Altman, but ultimately it's Nashville that feels more real, despite the fact that it rarely poses as a documentary. Altman and his collaborators capture daily life with close observations, watching Lily Tomlin and Ned Beatty interact with their kids at home, say. Guest is primarily focused on making us laugh and detours only occasionally, but affectionately, such as when Michael McKean hears Eugene Levy and Catherine O'Hara singing what he calls "that pretty song" on a backstage monitor and unironically asks Harry Shearer to turn up the volume. It furthers the plot — Guest wants all of the characters to witness the climax from the wings and needs to bring them together — but he could have accomplished the same thing with meanness. The mockumentarian is unexpectedly sweet this time out. The music, too, is silly but understated enough that in the right context it could probably be taken seriously. The main reason to see the movie is to watch the great cast having fun, although its size tends to squeeze the performances down to snippets.

Posted by davis | Link | Comments (1)
correction
We recently reported that Wes Craven was set to direct the long-awaited sequel to Last Year At Marienbad, called Next Year At Marienbad. But our sources may have been mistaken as the project seems to have been shelved. While the reasons for canceling the project are unclear, we speculate that it has something to do with Mr. Craven's plan to strip the story to it's core — murder in a large old European building — which may have been at odds with the studio's desire to capitalize on the current popularity of plots with twisted timelines by building a franchise around a mysterious, time-traveling cardsharp, played by Rod Serling in the original. Studios may also have gotten cold feet after watching the recent Russian Ark fail to earn $100 million worldwide. That film, too, takes place in a large old European building, and although it does not involve killing it does feature a number of dead people and, thus, may encroach on the same market. We apologize for any misinformation that we may have disseminated.
also
Since this web site's inception we have asserted that Knight Rider would never be adapted to the big screen. Sorry.
Posted by editor | Link | Other Corrections